IncriminateHow it works & interactions with other cards

What It Does

Incriminate allows you to select two target creatures, provided they are both controlled by the same player. Unlike many removal spells that destroy a target, this card forces the controller to sacrifice one of those two creatures. Because it results in a sacrifice, it bypasses keywords like Indestructible and Ward, though the targets themselves must still be legal when the spell is cast and when it resolves.

Resolving the Spell

First, you cast Incriminate and choose two target creatures controlled by the same opponent. When the spell resolves, both targets must still be legal; if one target becomes illegal (for example, by gaining Hexproof), the spell still resolves, and the opponent must sacrifice the remaining legal target. If both targets are still valid, the opponent chooses which one to send to the graveyard and which one stays on the field.

Common Mistakes

A common error is trying to target two creatures controlled by different players; the spell explicitly requires both targets to be controlled by the same person. Additionally, remember that since the opponent chooses which creature to sacrifice, they will almost always keep their most valuable piece. You cannot use this to force the sacrifice of a specific creature if they have a less important one targeted alongside it.

When to Play It

Incriminate is best used when your opponent has two high-value targets and any outcome is beneficial for you. It is also an excellent tool against creatures with Indestructible, as sacrifice effects do not count as destruction. Use it during your main phase to clear the way for an attack or to remove a pesky utility creature.

Interaction examples

Strategic Selection

You cast Incriminate targeting your opponent's two biggest blockers. Since they control both, the spell is legal. Upon resolution, your opponent evaluates their board and chooses to sacrifice one, allowing your attackers to potentially move past the remaining creature.

Bringing Back the Fallen

Reanimate

After casting Incriminate and forcing your opponent to sacrifice a powerful creature, you can then cast Reanimate. This allows you to target the creature they just sacrificed in their graveyard and bring it back to the battlefield under your own control.

Finding the Solution

Demonic Tutor

If your opponent has two dangerous creatures and you need a way to deal with them, you cast Demonic Tutor to search your library for Incriminate. You put Incriminate into your hand, shuffle, and then cast it to force the sacrifice of one of those threats immediately.