Collective Defiance is one of those cards players keep asking about. Here is, in plain words, what its official text says, the rulings published by Wizards of the Coast, and the combos players actually run.
Official card text
Escalate(Pay this cost for each mode chosen beyond the first.) Choose one or more — • Target player discards all the cards in their hand, then draws that many cards. • Collective Defiance deals 4 damage to target creature. • Collective Defiance deals 3 damage to target opponent or planeswalker.
Complete guide
Collective Defiance is a versatile red sorcery from the Eldritch Moon set that offers a modular approach to problem-solving. Thanks to its Escalate ability, it can function as a card filtering tool, creature removal, or a direct damage finisher all at once. Whether you need to refresh your hand or clear the board, this card adapts to the state of the game.
Understanding Escalate
Escalate is an additional cost you pay as you cast the spell. While the base cost of Collective Defiance is {1}{R}{R} for one mode, you may pay an additional {1} for each additional mode you wish to select. You must choose all modes and pay the total cost upfront; you cannot wait to see the results of one mode before deciding to add another. If you choose all three modes, the total cost will be {3}{R}{R}.
Resolution Order
When Collective Defiance resolves, you follow the instructions in the order they are printed on the card. First, the targeted player discards and draws. Second, the spell deals 4 damage to the targeted creature. Finally, it deals 3 damage to the targeted opponent or planeswalker. If a mode requires a target, and that target becomes illegal before resolution, that specific effect fails, but the remaining modes with legal targets will still resolve normally.
Common Mistakes
A common misconception is that Escalate changes the mana value of the spell. Even if you pay {3}{R}{R} to use all three modes, the mana value remains 3. Additionally, you cannot choose the same mode twice; for example, you cannot choose the second mode twice to deal 8 damage to one creature or 4 damage to two different creatures. However, if different modes allow for similar targets, you could potentially target the same player with the first and third modes.
Strategic Timing
Because Collective Defiance is a sorcery, you must cast it during your main phase when the stack is empty. It is particularly effective when you have a hand of redundant lands, as the first mode allows you to cycle those away while still impacting the board. If an effect allows you to cast this spell 'without paying its mana cost,' you still must pay the {1} Escalate cost for every mode chosen beyond the first.
Interaction examples
You spend {3}{R}{R} to choose all three modes. You target yourself to wheel your hand, an opponent's creature to destroy it, and the opponent directly. You first discard your hand and draw a fresh one, then the creature takes 4 damage, and finally, the opponent takes 3 damage.
Jeska's WillIf you cast Jeska's Will first and add a large amount of red mana, you can easily afford the Escalate costs of Collective Defiance. If you use the first mode of Collective Defiance to force an opponent to draw cards after you've used Jeska's Will, you can ensure they have a full hand for any subsequent 'hand size' triggers you might control.
Wheel of FortuneUnlike Wheel of Fortune, which forces everyone to draw exactly seven, Collective Defiance's first mode only affects one targeted player and only draws as many as they discarded. This makes it a more surgical tool; you can use it to fix your own hand without giving your opponents new resources, or target an opponent who just searched for a specific card to force them to lose it.
Guide written with AI from the official text and rulings. Official English text prevails.
How it works : Collective Defiance
Original English text — Wizards of the Coast / Scryfall
- #1· Wizards of the Coast
You choose all of your modes at once. You can’t wait to perform one mode’s actions and then decide to choose more modes.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #2· Wizards of the Coast
You can’t choose any one mode multiple times.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #3· Wizards of the Coast
If two of the chosen modes of an escalate spell target a creature, you may choose the same creature for each mode’s target, or choose different creatures. The same is true if the chosen modes target a player (or opponent).
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #4· Wizards of the Coast
If one target of an escalate spell becomes illegal, the other targets will still be affected. If all of the targets become illegal, the spell won’t resolve.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #5· Wizards of the Coast
Effects that reduce the cost of spells reduce the total cost, including any escalate costs added.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #6· Wizards of the Coast
If an effect allows you to cast a spell that has escalate without paying its mana cost, you pay escalate costs for that spell if you choose more than one mode.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #7· Wizards of the Coast
Additional costs don’t affect a spell’s mana value.
No other card is named in this ruling.
Legal formats
Commentaires
- Sois le premier à commenter cette carte.
Read next
Meta decks with Collective Defiance
No archived Top 8 deck with this card yet.