Tainted Remedy is one of those cards players keep asking about. Here is, in plain words, what its official text says, the rulings published by Wizards of the Coast, and the combos players actually run.
Official card text
If an opponent would gain life, that player loses that much life instead.
Complete guide
Tainted Remedy is a sinister enchantment that punishes opponents who rely on healing and recovery. Instead of watching your enemies flourish, this card turns their every attempt at gaining health into a painful loss of life.
What It Does
Tainted Remedy creates a replacement effect that specifically targets your opponents. It looks for any event where an opponent would gain life and modifies that event. Instead of the life total going up, the game processes it as a life loss for that exact same amount.
How It Resolves Step by Step
When an effect or ability would cause an opponent to gain life, Tainted Remedy intervenes before the life is added. First, the game identifies the amount of life to be gained. Second, the replacement effect replaces 'gain X life' with 'lose X life.' Finally, the opponent's life total is adjusted downward, potentially triggering 'whenever a player loses life' abilities.
Common Mistakes
A common misconception is that multiple copies of Tainted Remedy will stack to multiply life loss. However, once the first Tainted Remedy replaces the life gain with life loss, there is no longer a life gain event for a second copy to replace. Additionally, remember that this card only affects opponents; your own life gain remains unchanged.
When to Play It
This is a potent sideboard or mainboard tool against Lifelink-heavy decks or strategies involving infinite life combos. By turning their primary defensive mechanism into a lethal liability, you force them to stop their own engine or face immediate defeat.
Interaction examples
Phyrexian ArenaIf you control both Tainted Remedy and Phyrexian Arena, Tainted Remedy does nothing to you. At your upkeep, Phyrexian Arena causes you to draw a card and lose 1 life as normal, because Tainted Remedy only replaces life gain attempted by your opponents.
Black Market ConnectionsIf an opponent controls Black Market Connections while you have Tainted Remedy on the battlefield, the opponent still loses life as indicated by their chosen modes. Tainted Remedy does not interact with life loss, only life gain. If they were to use a different card to try and regain that lost life, Tainted Remedy would then step in to cause even more life loss.
Guide written with AI from the official text and rulings. Official English text prevails.
How it works : Tainted Remedy
Original English text — Wizards of the Coast / Scryfall
- #1· Wizards of the Coast
If more than one replacement effect tries to apply to a life gain event, the player who would gain life chooses the order in which they apply. For example, if a player who controls Alhammarret’s Archive would gain 3 life while Tainted Remedy is on the battlefield, that player may choose to have the 3 life become doubled to 6 life and then lose 6 life. The player may also choose to apply Tainted Remedy first, turning “gain 3 life” into “lose 3 life.” Alhammarret’s Archive would then not apply.
No other card is named in this ruling.
- #2· Wizards of the Coast
Having more than one Tainted Remedy on the battlefield doesn’t have any noticeable effect on life gain. Once the effect of one Tainted Remedy applies, there is no life gain for the others to apply to.
No other card is named in this ruling.
Popular combos
Real combos played by the community, sorted by popularity.
Beacon of Immortality + Tainted Remedy
- 1Cast Beacon of Immortality by paying
, causing target opponent to lose life equal to their life total due to Tainted Remedy. - 2The opponent loses the game due to having zero or less life.
Grove of the Burnwillows + Pili-Pala + Marvin, Murderous Mimic + Tainted Remedy
- 1Activate Marvin using Grove of the Burnwillows' second ability by tapping it, adding
or 
and causing each opponent to lose 1 life due to Tainted Remedy. - 2Activate Marvin using Pili-Pala's ability by paying
and untapping it, adding 
. - 3Repeat.
Grollub + Tainted Remedy + Volcano Hellion + Angel's Grace
- 1Cast Angel's Grace by paying , causing you to be unable to lose the game this turn.
- 2Cast Volcano Hellion by paying .
- 3Volcano Hellion enters the battlefield, dealing an arbitrarily large amount of damage to Grollub and reduing your lifetotal to one due to Angel's Grace.
- 4Grollub triggers, causing each opponent to lose life equal to the damage dealt to it due to Tainted Remedy.
- 5Each opponent loses the game due to having zero or less life.
Grove of the Burnwillows + Pili-Pala + Marvin, Murderous Mimic + Tainted Remedy
- 1Activate Llanowar Loamspeaker's second ability by tapping it, causing Grove of the Burnwillows to become a creature until end of turn.
- 2Activate Marvin using Grove of the Burnwillows' second ability by tapping it, adding or and causing each opponent to lose 1 life due to Tainted Remedy.
- 3Activate Marvin using Pili-Pala's ability by paying and untapping it, adding .
- 4Repeat from step 2.
Grove of the Burnwillows + Pili-Pala + Marvin, Murderous Mimic + Tainted Remedy
- 1Activate Wrenn and Realmbreaker's first loyalty ability by putting a loyalty counter on it, causing Grove of the Burnwillows to become a creature until end of turn.
- 2Activate Marvin using Grove of the Burnwillows' second ability by tapping it, adding or and causing each opponent to lose 1 life due to Tainted Remedy.
- 3Activate Marvin using Pili-Pala's ability by paying and untapping it, adding .
- 4Repeat from step 2.
Hive Mind + Revival // Revenge + Tainted Remedy
- 1Cast Revenge by paying
. - 2Hive Mind triggers, causing each opponent to copy Revenge.
- 3Resolve the first opponent's copy of Revenge, causing the opponent to lose life equal to their life total, and causing a different player to lose half their life total, rounded up.
- 4The opponent loses the game due to having zero life.
- 5Repeat from step 3 for each remaining opponent's copy of Revenge.
Grove of the Burnwillows + Pili-Pala + Marvin, Murderous Mimic + Tainted Remedy
- 1Activate Nissa's first loyalty ability by putting a loyalty counter on it, causing Grove of the Burnwillows to become a creature until end of turn.
- 2Activate Marvin using Grove of the Burnwillows' second ability by tapping it, adding or and causing each opponent to lose 1 life due to Tainted Remedy.
- 3Activate Marvin using Pili-Pala's ability by paying and untapping it, adding .
- 4Repeat from step 2.
Grollub + Tainted Remedy + Volcano Hellion + Platinum Emperion
- 1Cast Volcano Hellion by paying .
- 2Volcano Hellion enters the battlefield, dealing an arbitrarily large amount of damage to you and Grollub.
- 3Grollub triggers, causing each opponent to lose life equal to the damage dealt to it due to Tainted Remedy.
- 4Each opponent loses the game due to having zero or less life.
Legal formats
Commentaires
- Sois le premier à commenter cette carte.
Read next
Meta decks with Tainted Remedy
No archived Top 8 deck with this card yet.